CJEU Declines to Rule on Malta’s Bill 55 in Key Gambling Case

CJEU Declines to Rule on Malta’s Bill 55 in Key Gambling Case

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has declined to provide a definitive ruling on the compatibility of Malta’s Bill 55 with EU law. This decision arose in the context of the Spielerschutz Sigma case, a high-profile dispute involving cross-border enforcement of judgments against Maltese-licensed gambling operators.

Bill 55 allows Maltese courts to refuse recognition of certain foreign judgments against locally licensed gambling companies if the actions involved violate Malta’s gambling regulations. This has been criticized for potentially undermining judicial cooperation within the EU, particularly affecting players seeking to recover losses from unlicensed or non-compliant operators.

The case originated when Austrian litigation finance firm Spielerschutz Sigma sued several Maltese gambling companies in Austrian courts, successfully obtaining awards for players. However, attempts to enforce these judgments in Malta under Bill 55 were blocked by Maltese courts, prompting Spielerschutz Sigma to seek damages from its legal advisors for allegedly erroneous guidance regarding the enforceability of these judgments.

When the matter was referred to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling, the court ruled the request inadmissible, stating that the dispute concerned whether the legal advice was reasonable at the time it was given, independent of the question of Bill 55’s compliance with EU law.

Consequently, the CJEU’s decision refrained from addressing the substantive compatibility of Bill 55 with EU law, effectively leaving the legislation’s status unsettled. This outcome is pragmatic for Malta’s gambling sector, which depends on Bill 55 to limit exposure to foreign claims, but leaves ongoing legal uncertainty for players and other stakeholders.

The controversy has significant ramifications for cross-border gambling litigation within the EU, as operators licensed in Malta benefit from legal protections not available in other jurisdictions. Meanwhile, players in countries such as Austria continue to face challenges enforcing compensation claims against operators that were unlicensed locally but held Maltese licenses.

As several similar cases remain pending or under consideration in European courts, this legal area remains dynamic and uncertain. Future rulings could provide clearer guidance on the balance between national gambling regulations and EU judicial cooperation mechanisms.

Operators and affiliates should monitor developments closely, as the legal environment around enforcement of gambling-related claims may impact risk assessments and compliance strategies when dealing with Maltese operators or their players.

Author’s comment

“This ruling highlights ongoing ambiguities in EU cross-border gambling enforcement, emphasizing the need for operators and affiliates to stay vigilant about legal risks related to licenses and claim recoveries. Media buyers should consider these uncertainties when targeting regulated markets where Maltese licenses are prevalent.”

Yaroslav MishchenkoLinkedIn

Source: GamblingNews