Regulatory Challenges Mount for Prediction Markets as States and Federal Agencies Clash

Regulatory Challenges Mount for Prediction Markets as States and Federal Agencies Clash

Several recent legal and regulatory developments illustrate the growing challenges facing prediction market platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket, which are headquartered in New York. These firms offer markets on sports, politics, culture, and other events, but their operations have drawn increased scrutiny from state and federal authorities.

New York Attorney General Letitia James recently refiled a motion seeking a temporary restraining order (TRO) against Kalshi, aiming to halt the platform from offering event contracts within or to residents of New York without a state license. The filing also seeks to prevent sales to individuals under 21, aligning with New York’s legal sports betting age.

The TRO extends to advertising activities, specifically referencing college campuses and university media channels, highlighting concerns over marketing practices targeting vulnerable or younger populations. This move underscores the state’s intent to strictly regulate prediction markets as akin to gambling activities under state law.

In parallel, New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani publicly criticized the expansion of betting opportunities, expressing worries about societal impacts if more aspects of life become subject to wagers. Although he stated he has not personally used platforms like Kalshi or Polymarket, his remarks reflect political pressures on the industry at the municipal level.

At the federal level, a bipartisan coalition of 43 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia voiced opposition to a Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) proposal that would classify sports-related event contracts as swaps, a type of financial derivative. They argue this oversteps federal authority, undercuts state consumer protections, and could allow platforms to circumvent licensing and responsible gambling measures.

The coalition’s formal comment stresses that sports-event contracts resemble traditional sports betting more than financial derivatives, challenging the CFTC’s interpretation and highlighting judicial rulings limiting federal jurisdiction. They also question the legitimacy of the CFTC’s rulemaking process, citing an insufficient quorum.

Meanwhile, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 in favor of Maryland regulators pursuing enforcement actions against Kalshi for selling sports-event contracts without a license. This decision contrasts with mixed rulings from other circuits, indicating ongoing legal uncertainty. Kalshi has expressed skepticism about the fragmented judicial opinions, suggesting the issue may ultimately require U.S. Supreme Court resolution.

The evolving legal landscape presents practical implications for operators and media buyers in the prediction markets space. Platforms must navigate varying state regulations, potential advertising restrictions, and federal challenges that may impact licensing requirements and marketing strategies. Close attention to jurisdictional developments and compliance measures is essential to sustain operations and mitigate regulatory risks.

Author’s comment

“The recent moves by New York and the coalition of state attorneys general exemplify mounting resistance against prediction markets operating without traditional gambling licenses. Operators and advertisers should monitor evolving regulations closely, as states push to impose stricter controls which could affect user acquisition and content placement strategies.”

Yaroslav MishchenkoLinkedIn

Source: CDC Gaming