43 States Oppose CFTC's Bid to Regulate Sports Prediction Markets

43 States Oppose CFTC's Bid to Regulate Sports Prediction Markets

The attorneys general (AGs) of 43 states plus Washington, D.C., have formally opposed a recent proposal by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to regulate sports prediction markets under its derivatives authority. This bipartisan coalition argues that sports-related contracts should remain under state gambling laws rather than federal commodities rules.

The rule proposed in October by the CFTC expands the definition of «swaps» under the Commodity Exchange Act to include contracts linked to sporting events, politics, culture, and weather. The agency believes this extension clarifies its jurisdiction and addresses regulatory ambiguities concerning such products.

Leading the opposition is the Ohio Attorney General, joined by peers from Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee, and Utah. Their formal comments — submitted by the November 18 deadline for public input — contend the CFTC lacks Congressional authority to regulate sports betting as derivatives.

The coalition emphasizes that sports prediction contracts are essentially bets and should therefore be governed by existing state gambling frameworks. This aligns with recent federal appellate court decisions casting doubt on the CFTC’s approach to sports wagering under its current mandate.

Moreover, the attorneys general raise concerns about regulatory and consumer protection gaps the CFTC’s rule could create. They warn that, if classified as swaps, prediction market operators could sidestep state licensing, age restrictions, taxation, and responsible gambling rules.

There is also apprehension that established sportsbooks might reclassify themselves as prediction markets to avoid more stringent regulations. The coalition argues that the proposed rule, lacking a full commission quorum (only one commissioner currently serving), should not proceed.

Conversely, CFTC Chairman Michael Selig maintains that event contracts fall within the commission’s jurisdiction under the federal commodities laws. He states these markets help Americans hedge financial risks, speculate on future events, and generate information about potential outcomes.

This jurisdictional dispute coincides with rapid growth in prediction market activity, particularly in sports. A recent American Gaming Association poll indicates 82% of U.S. adults favor regulating prediction markets as gambling, not financial derivatives. In October, the average daily trading volume in prediction markets reached $4.13 billion, with sports contracts accounting for 78% of that activity.

Author’s comment

“This development highlights the ongoing tension between federal and state oversight in emerging gaming-related financial products. Operators and media buyers should monitor regulatory shifts closely, as classification impacts licensing, advertising standards, and compliance obligations.”

Yaroslav MishchenkoLinkedIn

Source: GamblingNews