Brazil’s AGU Submissions to Supreme Court Question Evidence Behind Online Betting Ban

Brazil’s AGU Submissions to Supreme Court Question Evidence Behind Online Betting Ban

Brazil’s Attorney General’s Office (AGU) has submitted four documents to the Supreme Federal Court (STF) in support of the government’s suspension of online betting and gambling. However, an independent analysis by BNLData highlights inconsistencies and questions whether the data fully supports the government’s rationale.

The documents were filed on November 16 amid several Direct Actions of Unconstitutionality (ADIs 8024, 8027, 8028, 8035) overseen by Justice Luiz Fux. The AGU, through Deputy Attorney General Flavio José Roman, described these submissions as part of an «active monitoring and oversight of public policy,» involving multiple federal agencies producing studies and evaluations.

Notably, only one document predates the provisional measure issued on September 25, which sought to suspend online betting activities. This technical note from September 9 references scientific literature backing previous cases from 2024. The other three documents were produced after the measure: a Health Ministry memo dated September 30 (signed October 1), an October 29 report by the Secretariat of Prizes and Betting, and a November 10 report from the National Secretariat for Digital Rights.

The Health Ministry memo acknowledged that access to betting data via the government’s SIGAP system has not yet been implemented under a cooperation agreement, limiting the ability to assess the full impact. Consequently, the ministry relied on BNLData statistics from the first half of 2026 regarding gambling income and registered players.

Discrepancies emerge in health statistics and suicide risk data. For example, Health Minister Alexandre Padilha cited a suicide risk statistic fifteen times higher among individuals with gambling disorders based on a Swedish study, whereas the ministry’s own documents referenced a Norwegian study identifying a five-and-a-half-fold risk increase, and a lower risk among patients without other psychiatric disorders.

Additional inconsistencies were reported regarding estimates of at-risk bettors, demand for public healthcare, self-exclusion registrations, and betting revenue figures between the Secretariat of Prizes and Betting and the Health Ministry for the first half of 2026.

The Health Ministry’s reports also emphasize that most cited studies are observational, complicating causal conclusions, and underline a lack of specific Brazilian data on online betting. Despite this caveat, the higher suicide risk estimate was presented to the STF as part of the government’s case.

The Secretariat of Prizes and Betting reported significant enforcement actions including blocking over 52,000 URLs by mid-2026 and numerous sanctioning procedures. However, the National Secretariat for Digital Rights observed over 60,000 cases of illegal betting promotion after the suspension, suggesting that illegal activity persists despite the ban. BNLData interprets these findings as evidence that the suspension hasn’t fully controlled the illicit market.

The AGU has requested the STF to consider these four documents as part of the ongoing constitutional review of the government’s suspension of online betting. The timing, varying data quality, and acknowledged limitations pose challenges as the court assesses the measure’s justification and constitutionality.

Author’s comment

“This case highlights the complexities regulators face when relying on evolving and sometimes imperfect data during rapid policy shifts in iGaming. For operators and media buyers, it emphasizes the importance of monitoring legal developments and data transparency in regulated markets.”

Yaroslav MishchenkoLinkedIn

Source: iGaming Today