Four leading Oklahoma tribes recently faced a setback in their legal efforts to overturn gaming compacts negotiated between the state and two rival tribes in 2020. Despite an earlier state Supreme Court decision declaring these agreements invalid under state law, a federal judge dismissed the tribes’ lawsuit in March 2024.
The four tribes—the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, and Citizen Potawatomi nations—challenged the new compacts signed by Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt with the Comanche Nation and the Otoe-Missouria Tribe. These agreements adjusted revenue sharing and expanded gaming options, including provisions for sports betting and additional casino facilities.
Governor Stitt had argued that the previous 2004 compacts expired on January 1, 2020, and needed renegotiation, aiming to increase state revenue from tribal casinos. Tribal leaders contended that the old agreements were set to automatically renew for another 15 years, making the new compacts unnecessary.
In 2021, a federal court sided with the tribes on continued gaming operations, allowing Class III gaming to proceed. Nonetheless, the new compacts featured a lower revenue share of 4.5%, compared to rates reaching up to 10% under the 2004 agreements, balanced by expanded gambling permissions.
The US Department of the Interior permitted these compacts to take effect under a «no-action approval» after its review period elapsed. However, the Oklahoma Supreme Court later ruled that Governor Stitt exceeded his authority by negotiating gaming activities, such as sports betting, not yet authorized by state law, declaring the compacts invalid.
Following this, the plaintiff tribes argued that federal approval of the compacts unfairly advantaged their competitors. Yet, US District Judge Timothy J. Kelly dismissed these claims, citing a lack of clear harm or increased market competition since the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria already operated casinos prior to the disputed compacts.
Judge Kelly also noted that the anticipated expansion of gaming options and new casino establishments remained hypothetical, as legal and regulatory procedures had not been initiated. He further found no evidence that revenue-sharing differences had allowed rivals to offer superior jackpots or amenities.
While this ruling does not address the federal legality of the compacts nor overturn the state Supreme Court decision invalidating them, it nonetheless leaves the tribes without legal recourse to challenge the agreements at the federal level. The dispute highlights ongoing tensions between tribal sovereignty, state authority, and federal oversight in Oklahoma’s gaming sector.
Author’s comment
“This ruling underscores the challenges tribal operators face when disputes involve overlapping state and federal jurisdictions. Operators and media buyers should monitor evolving gaming regulations and compact negotiations in Oklahoma, as legal uncertainties may impact advertising strategies and market competition.”
Yaroslav MishchenkoSource: Casino.org News