Forty-three state attorneys general and the District of Columbia have formally requested that the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) abandon its proposed rule deeming sports event contracts as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). This collective action challenges the federal agency’s expanding regulatory stance over sports-related trading products.
On October 9, the CFTC published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking aiming to amend the definition of swaps to explicitly include contracts based on sports, political, cultural, and weather events. This move would classify various event contracts as derivatives, subject to CFTC oversight.
The attorneys general argue that categorizing sports event contracts as swaps encroaches on state regulatory authority and consumer protections. They contend the CFTC lacks statutory authority to redefine swaps in this way, warning that it could undermine states’ ability to regulate sports betting and related prediction markets effectively.
Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, one of the letter’s co-authors, emphasized that a sports bet is not inherently a derivative just because the CFTC designates it as such. He criticized the agency for overstepping powers not granted by Congress and for dismissing federal court rulings and state-level consumer safeguards.
From the CFTC perspective, the commission maintains that under the Commodity Exchange Act it has exclusive jurisdiction over swaps, which, in its view, include sports event contracts. Michael Selig, the CFTC chair appointed during the Trump administration, has defended this jurisdiction, describing event contracts as commodity derivatives used for hedging, speculation, and information dissemination.
The CFTC has previously allowed prediction markets to self-certify sports events on their platforms, a move that drew criticism from various stakeholders citing consumer protection concerns and regulatory overreach.
A notable procedural objection from the attorneys general is that the CFTC currently operates with only one commissioner, raising questions about whether the agency has the necessary quorum to enact such a significant rule change. They interpret the Commodity Exchange Act to require at least two commissioners for decision-making, implying current actions by a sole commissioner could be procedurally invalid.
Recently, President Trump nominated two new commissioners in an effort to fill vacancies at the CFTC, which might address quorum concerns and influence the agency’s regulatory direction on these event contracts. However, the debate illustrates ongoing tensions between federal regulatory ambitions and state powers, particularly in the evolving landscape of sports betting and prediction markets.
Author’s comment
“This development signals potential regulatory clashes impacting sports betting operators and affiliate marketers. Industry stakeholders should monitor the evolving CFTC rulemaking and states' responses to anticipate compliance demands and jurisdictional boundaries.”
Yaroslav MishchenkoSource: Casino.org News